Home Coverage Watch

Leaving the California FAIR Plan: how homeowners get back to a regular insurer

Updated November 14, 2026.

If your home ended up on the California FAIR Plan, you're far from alone, and you may not have to stay there forever. Here's what the FAIR Plan is, why so many homes landed on it, and what homeowners do to move back to a regular insurer.

What the FAIR Plan is

The FAIR Plan is California's insurer of last resort: an association of the state's licensed property insurers, set up by law to provide basic fire insurance when no other option is reasonably available. Because it covers basic fire risk, homeowners commonly pair it with a separate "difference in conditions" policy from a private insurer for other risks, such as theft, liability and water damage. The FAIR Plan's site describes this supplemental coverage.

It has grown fast. The FAIR Plan had 698,307 policies in force (homes and businesses) as of September 2026, up 157% since September 2022, according to its own statistics, which also break the count down by county and ZIP code.

Why so many homes ended up there

Wildfire losses, rising rebuilding and reinsurance costs, and rate rules that insurers said didn't reflect wildfire risk led several large insurers to stop writing new homeowners policies in 2022 and 2023, or to cap how many they'd write. Homes in high-risk areas, and sometimes homes that simply came up for renewal, had nowhere else to go.

Why the picture is starting to change

Under the Department of Insurance's Sustainable Insurance Strategy, insurers can use wildfire catastrophe models in their rates if they commit to write more homes in wildfire-distressed areas. Several have made commitments or announced plans to reopen. We keep a dated log of insurers reopening in California.

What homeowners do to get back to a regular insurer

  1. Work with an independent agent or broker. Unlike an agent tied to one company, they can check many insurers at once, including smaller and newer ones that don't advertise much.
  2. Ask to be re-shopped at every renewal, and whenever an insurer announces it's reopening. Insurers' appetite for homes changes, sometimes by area, and nobody tells you automatically.
  3. Make the home easier to insure. Insurers increasingly look at defensible space, ember-resistant vents, roof type and other mitigation. Some new business is tied to it directly: State Farm's September 2026 filing would open new policies to homes meeting IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home standards (source). See wildfireprepared.org.
  4. Keep your documents ready. Your current declarations page, roof age, any mitigation work and photos make a quote faster when an opening appears.

Don't want to keep checking? Tell us your ZIP code and current insurer, and we'll email you when an insurer starts accepting new homes near you. Free.

Watch my ZIP code